Tutu's Top 7 Must-Try Products at Tutu’s Pantry
Ellie, founder of Tutu’s Pantry and her favorite products.
When you walk into Tutu’s Pantry in Kihei, you’re not just shopping—you’re stepping into a treasure trove of flavors, scents, and locally crafted magic. Owned by Ellie, this beloved spot celebrates the essence of Maui with every jar, bottle, and bag on the shelf. But when asked to pick her seven favorite products, even Ellie had a tough time. With so many incredible locally made items, narrowing it down was like picking a favorite sunset (nearly impossible). After much deliberation, here’s the ultimate list of must-tries that will make your taste buds dance and your heart sing.
1. Tutu's Pantry Macadamia Nut Lavender Seasoning
Imagine the floral notes of lavender paired with the rich, buttery flavor of macadamia nuts—this seasoning is pure magic. Perfect for sprinkling on roasted veggies, grilled fish, or even popcorn for an elevated snack. It’s Ellie’s secret weapon for turning everyday meals into gourmet creations.
2. Maui Chili Oil
Bold, flavorful, and just the right amount of heat, Maui Chili Oil is your new kitchen MVP. Whether drizzled over pizza, mixed into pasta, or paired with fresh bread, it’s a fiery hug mixed with delicious garlic and onion bits from the island. Pro tip: Keep it on your table—it’ll quickly become a mealtime staple.
3. Volcano Spice Banana Coconut Curry Hot Sauce
This is the sauce you didn’t know you needed but won’t be able to live without. Sweet banana, creamy coconut, and a gentle curry kick create a flavor explosion. Use it to liven up grilled chicken, shrimp skewers, or even as a tropical dip for fries. One taste, and you’ll be hooked.
4. Tutu's Pantry Guava Butter
If sunshine had a flavor, it’d be Tutu’s Pantry Guava Butter. Sweet, tangy, and silky-smooth, it’s a spreadable piece of paradise. Slather it on toast, pancakes, or even mix it into yogurt for a fruity twist. Ellie swears it’s the ultimate way to start your day on an aloha note.
5. Goat Milk Coconut Rum Caramel from Haleakala Creamery
This decadent caramel is a revelation. The combination of goat milk, coconut, and rum creates a rich, luxurious treat that’s perfect for drizzling over ice cream, dipping apples, or just eating straight out of the jar (no judgment). Haleakala Creamery has truly bottled indulgence.
6. North Shore Goodies Sea Salt Caramel Peanut Butter
Peanut butter lovers, prepare to fall in love. This isn’t your average spread—it’s creamy, nutty, and swirled with sea salt caramel for the ultimate sweet-and-salty experience. Whether spread on toast, spooned into smoothies, or enjoyed by the spoonful, it’s as addictive as it sounds.
7. Kupa’a Farm Lilikoi Spread
Lilikoi (passion fruit) is a quintessential Hawaiian flavor, and this jelly captures its bright, tangy essence perfectly. Spread it on biscuits, pair it with cheese, or use it to glaze meats for a tropical flair. Ellie loves how it adds a little Maui magic to anything it touches.
Why Stop at Seven?
Let’s be real—this list only scratches the surface of what Tutu’s Pantry has to offer. From fragrant candles to handcrafted beauty products, there’s so much more to explore. But these seven picks are a great place to start your journey into Maui’s local treasures.
Whether you’re stocking up for yourself or picking up gifts, Tutu’s Pantry is a must-visit for anyone looking to bring the spirit of Maui home. Stop by, say hi to Ellie, try all the delicious samples, and don’t be surprised if you leave with more than you planned—these flavors are just too good to resist!
